Rent or buy a home: compare the long-term financial outcome
A mortgage payment and a rent payment do not tell the whole story. Buying builds home equity, but it also ties up your down payment and brings maintenance, property taxes and transaction costs. Renting leaves more money available to invest in some scenarios. This rent vs buy calculator compares the estimated net wealth of both options over the number of years you expect to stay, using your own housing costs and growth assumptions.
How to use the rent vs buy calculator
- Enter the purchase price and monthly rent for comparable homes in the same area. Choose one currency for all amounts; changing the currency label does not convert your inputs.
- Set your down payment, annual mortgage rate, mortgage term and expected years of residence. The loan term and the time you plan to stay can be different.
- Open the cost and growth assumptions. Adjust property tax, insurance, maintenance, purchase and selling costs, home appreciation, rent increases and investment returns.
- Review the wealth difference, chart and yearly table. Try a shorter stay, lower appreciation or a different investment return to see how sensitive the result is to your assumptions.
The costs of buying a home go beyond the mortgage
The monthly mortgage result includes principal and interest on a fixed-rate loan. Principal repayments reduce your debt rather than disappearing as an expense. Property tax and maintenance are calculated as percentages of the changing home value, while annual insurance stays fixed. Purchase closing costs are paid upfront, and selling costs are deducted from the future sale price. These transaction costs can make a short period of ownership relatively expensive.
How home equity and the renter’s investments are compared
Both options start with equal capital and use the same monthly budget. The renter invests the amount the buyer spends on the down payment and purchase closing costs. Each month, whichever option has lower housing costs invests the difference. Buyer net wealth includes those investments plus the home’s sale value, less selling costs and the remaining mortgage. Renter wealth is the investment balance. The comparison measures estimated wealth, not just total payments or monthly savings.
What does the rent vs buy break-even year mean?
The break-even result is the first year-end at which buying produces at least as much net wealth as renting within your selected period. It assumes the home is sold at that point. A later move gives buying more time to offset transaction costs, but does not guarantee it will win. The advantage can reverse as rents, home values and investments grow at different rates. Check the full yearly table rather than relying on the first crossover alone.
Assumptions to check before making a decision
Rent changes annually; home values and investments grow monthly at rates equivalent to your annual assumptions. The model excludes tax deductions, taxes on investments, homeowners association fees, mortgage insurance and moving costs. Results are nominal amounts, not adjusted for inflation. Use local quotes and realistic estimates, and consider flexibility, repair responsibilities and the cash reserve you would need after buying.
Renting vs buying: frequently asked questions
Is renting always throwing money away?
No. Rent pays for a place to live and flexibility. Owners also have costs that do not build equity, such as interest, taxes, insurance and repairs. Renting can produce more wealth if the money saved is invested and its returns outweigh the financial benefits of ownership.
How many years should I stay before buying is worth it?
There is no universal five-year or ten-year rule. The answer depends on the local price-to-rent relationship, mortgage rate, transaction costs and future growth. Enter your expected stay and compare several nearby time horizons.
Does a larger down payment always make buying better?
A larger down payment reduces the mortgage and its interest costs, but also leaves less money available to invest. The calculator weighs both effects. It does not include mortgage insurance, so any savings from avoiding that charge need separate consideration.
Are the rent vs buy results adjusted for inflation?
No. All amounts are nominal, so a home value or investment balance 20 years from now is shown in future money rather than today's purchasing power. Both options are treated the same way, so the wealth difference between them is still a fair basis for comparison. To see what a future amount is worth today, run it through the inflation calculator.
Why does the investment return change the answer so much?
Much of the renter's wealth comes from investing the down payment, the purchase closing costs and any monthly savings. A higher assumed return makes that money grow faster, while a lower one makes home equity relatively more attractive. Because the effect compounds over many years, test a cautious return as well as an optimistic one before relying on the result.
Explore your housing and investment assumptions
Use the mortgage calculator to examine loan payments, the investment calculator to explore returns, and the inflation calculator to understand how purchasing power changes. Testing each assumption on its own makes it easier to see which input moves the rent vs buy result the most.
Link with your values
Add these parameters to this page’s address to open it with the values filled in, for example to share a calculation or to link to it from an AI assistant. The result is calculated in the browser: the page HTML shows an example for the default values, and the tool sets the data-url-params attribute once the link’s values are applied.
| Parameter | Value | If omitted |
|---|---|---|
currency | ISO 4217 code, for example USD or EUR | your saved or detected currency |
home_priceHome price | amount without a currency symbol; allowed 1–1000000000 | required |
rent_monthlyMonthly rent | amount without a currency symbol; allowed 0–10000000 | required |
down_payment_pctDown payment (%) | percent: 6.5 means 6.5%; allowed 0–100 | required |
interest_rate_pctMortgage rate (% per year) | percent: 6.5 means 6.5%; allowed 0–50 | required |
term_yearsMortgage term (years) | whole number; allowed 1–50 | default 30 |
yearsYears of residence | whole number; allowed 1–50 | required |
property_tax_rate_pctProperty tax (% per year) | percent: 6.5 means 6.5%; allowed 0–20 | default 1 |
home_insurance_yearlyHome insurance (per year) | amount without a currency symbol; allowed 0–10000000 | default 1200 |
maintenance_pctMaintenance (% per year) | percent: 6.5 means 6.5%; allowed 0–20 | default 1 |
closing_costs_pctPurchase closing costs (%) | percent: 6.5 means 6.5%; allowed 0–100 | default 3 |
selling_costs_pctSelling costs (%) | percent: 6.5 means 6.5%; allowed 0–100 | default 6 |
home_appreciation_pctHome appreciation (% per year) | percent: 6.5 means 6.5%; allowed -20–20 | default 3 |
rent_growth_pctRent increase (% per year) | percent: 6.5 means 6.5%; allowed -20–20 | default 3 |
annual_return_pctInvestment return (% per year) | percent: 6.5 means 6.5%; allowed -20–20 | default 5 |
Examples
?home_price=450000&rent_monthly=2200&down_payment_pct=10&interest_rate_pct=6.75&years=7?currency=EUR&home_price=320000&rent_monthly=1300&down_payment_pct=25&interest_rate_pct=3.9&term_years=25&years=15&annual_return_pct=6
Write decimals with a point. Encode a space as %20, + as %2B, # as %23 and & as %26.
Result elements: [data-result-block="rent_vs_buy_calculator"]